Who Governs the Governors?

I have come to think that Australian universities are public institutions with private habits of governance. Their councils are created by legislation, yet they often fill their own vacancies, answer to no shareholders and face no electorate. When something goes wrong, the people best placed to notice are often the least able to say so.

The Swinburne review reported this week is a case in point, and what struck me was less the findings than what followed them. Investigators found a culture of fear and mistrust, settled staff exits, non-disclosure agreements, and a vice-chancellor who did not feel safe taking her concerns to her own council. Yet no adverse findings were made, because the specific allegations were never put to the chancellor, and the council declared its full confidence in him. The process diagnosed the problem and left untouched the structure that produced it.

That, to my mind, is the deeper issue. Governance fails not only through misconduct but through design: councils that oversee themselves, charters amended to widen a chancellor's reach into management, and complaints channels that staff will not use for fear of retribution.

I welcome the reforms now under way. Canberra has introduced national governance standards, and parliamentary inquiries in Victoria and New South Wales have proposed more elected staff and student members and independent council secretariats. But I doubt that rules alone will fix a culture in which accountability runs upward to the chancellor rather than outward to the public.

#HigherEducation #UniversityGovernance #Accountability #Swinburne

Next
Next

Weak corporate governance and its flow-on effects